Arc welding and laser welding are two popular welding methods used in various industries for joining metal components. While both techniques can produce strong and durable welds, they have different characteristics and advantages that make them suitable for different applications. In this article, we will explore the key differences between arc welding and laser welding, focusing on the heat source, equipment, speed, power, and other factors that affect their performance and quality.

I. What Is Arc Welding?

Arc welding is a welding process that uses an electric arc to join metals. The electric arc is generated by passing a current between an electrode (a metal rod that can be consumable or non-consumable) and the workpiece. The heat from the arc melts the metals, forming a weld pool of molten material that solidifies upon cooling. To protect the weld from atmospheric contamination, a shielding gas or a flux is often used.

Arc welding is one of the most common and versatile welding methods, as it can be applied to a wide range of metals and thicknesses. It is also relatively inexpensive and easy to operate, making it suitable for various settings and environments. Some of the industries that use arc welding include construction, automotive, shipbuilding, oil and gas, and repair and fabrication.

There are several types of arc welding processes, such as:

1. Shielded Metal Arc Welding (SMAW): Also known as stick welding, this is the simplest and most widely used arc welding process. It uses a consumable electrode coated with a flux that produces a gas shield around the arc and the weld pool. The flux also provides filler material and slag that covers the weld and protects it from oxidation.

2. Gas Metal Arc Welding (GMAW): Also known as metal inert gas (MIG) welding, this is a semi-automatic or automatic arc welding process that uses a continuously fed consumable electrode and an inert or semi-inert shielding gas. The gas prevents contamination and spatter, resulting in a clean and smooth weld. GMAW is fast and efficient and can be used for thin or thick metals.

3. Flux-Cored Arc Welding (FCAW): This is a variation of GMAW that uses a tubular consumable electrode filled with a flux instead of a solid wire. The flux provides shielding and filler material, and can also enhance the weld properties and penetration. FCAW is suitable for outdoor welding, as it can withstand wind and other environmental factors.

4. Gas Tungsten Arc Welding (GTAW): Also known as tungsten inert gas (TIG) welding, this is a manual arc welding process that uses a non-consumable tungsten electrode and an inert shielding gas. The electrode does not melt, so a separate filler material is often used. GTAW produces high-quality welds with minimal distortion and spatter and can be used for thin or delicate metals.

II. What Is Laser Welding?

Laser welding is a welding process that uses a focused laser beam to join metals. The laser beam is concentrated on a small point, creating a high-intensity heat that melts the metals, forming a weld pool that cools and solidifies. The laser welding process is contactless, meaning that there is no direct contact between the welding equipment and the workpiece.

Laser welding is a precise and efficient welding method, as it can control the heat input and output, and produce narrow and deep welds with minimal distortion and defects. It is also fast and flexible, as it can be used for complex and intricate shapes and geometries. Some of the industries that use laser welding include aerospace, medical, electronics, automotive, and jewelry.

There are two main types of laser welding processes, such as:

1. Conduction Laser Welding: This is a low-power laser welding process that produces shallow and wide welds. The laser beam heats the surface of the metals, creating a heat conduction that melts the material and forms a weld pool. The weld pool is larger than the laser spot, resulting in a smooth and uniform weld. Conduction laser welding is suitable for thin or heat-sensitive metals, such as gold or copper.

2. Keyhole Laser Welding: This is a high-power laser welding process that produces deep and narrow welds. The laser beam penetrates the surface of the metals, creating a vapor cavity or a keyhole that acts as a waveguide for the laser. The keyhole transfers the heat to the surrounding material, melting it and forming a weld pool. The weld pool is smaller than the laser spot, resulting in a high aspect ratio and a strong weld. Keyhole laser welding is suitable for thick or hard metals, such as steel or titanium.

III. Arc Welding vs. Laser Welding: The Comparison

Arc welding and laser welding have different advantages and disadvantages, depending on the application and the requirements. Here are some of the factors that can help you compare and choose the best welding method for your needs:

1. Heat Source: Arc welding uses an electric arc as the heat source, while laser welding uses a laser beam as the heat source. The electric arc is more diffuse and spreads over a larger area, while the laser beam is more focused and concentrated on a smaller point. This means that arc welding produces more heat and can cause distortions and residual stresses in the metal, while laser welding produces less heat and minimizes distortions and deformations.

2. Equipment: Arc welding requires an electrode, a power source, and a shielding gas or a flux, while laser welding requires a laser source, a focusing optic, and a shielding gas. The equipment for arc welding is more simple and affordable, but also more bulky and heavy, while the equipment for laser welding is more complex and expensive, but also more compact and light. The equipment for arc welding is also more prone to wear and tear, requiring more maintenance and replacement, while the equipment for laser welding is more durable and reliable, requiring less maintenance and replacement.

3. Speed: Arc welding is slower than laser welding, as it takes more time to strike the arc, melt the metals, and fill the weld pool. Laser welding is faster than arc welding, as it can quickly heat and melt the metals, and produce a weld in a single pass. The speed of arc welding also depends on the type and size of the electrode, the current and voltage settings, and the skill of the operator, while the speed of laser welding depends on the type and power of the laser, the focal length, and diameter of the optic, and the automation of the process.

4. Power: Arc welding consumes more power than laser welding, as it requires a high current and voltage to generate the electric arc and maintain the weld pool. Laser welding consumes less power than arc welding, as it requires a low current and voltage to generate the laser beam and create the weld. The power consumption of arc welding also varies depending on the type and size of the electrode, the current and voltage settings, and the length and frequency of the arc, while the power consumption of laser welding varies depending on the type and power of the laser, the focal length and diameter of the optic, and the duration and intensity of the beam.

5. Quality: Arc welding produces lower-quality welds than laser welding, as it can cause spatter, slag, porosity, cracks, and other defects in the weld. Laser welding produces higher quality welds than arc welding, as it can prevent contamination, spatter, porosity, cracks, and other defects in the weld. The quality of arc welding also depends on the type and quality of the electrode, the shielding gas or the flux, and the skill of the operator, while the quality of laser welding depends on the type and quality of the laser, the focusing optic, and the shielding gas.

IV. Conclusion

Arc welding and laser welding are two different welding methods that have their own strengths and weaknesses. Arc welding is more economical and versatile, but also more heat-intensive and less precise, while laser welding is more precise and efficient, but also more costly and complex. The best welding method for your project will depend on factors such as the material, thickness, shape, speed, power, quality, and budget. You can also combine arc welding and laser welding to achieve the best of both worlds, such as using laser welding for the root pass and arc welding for the filler pass or using arc welding for the main weld and laser welding for the finishing touch.

Related articles:

1. 10 Reasons to Use Laser Welding

2. Traditional Welding vs. Laser Welding

3. Laser Welding vs MIG Welding: the Basics

4. Laser Welding vs TIG Welding - What’s the Difference

5. Fiber Laser Welding: Advantages, Systems and Applications